Bestikas as manager offered me 4 mill for a 94k 26 yo mid!!!

_________________
MArk

5-7m on my experience



Based on that one i canceled the action.

There is something suspicious. I will investigate it when i have time. Till that time please don't make any deal with Besiktas. I will reverse it whatever the price is.

_________________

10m us still fair.

_________________
SK Slavia Praha

GIF


NEVER CHANGED TEAM

_________________
Helder Rodrigues
Sport Lisboa e Benfica
Colombia

Looks like today trade between Spartak Moskva FC and Trabzonspor is pretty suspicious... Managers of both teams looks pretty linked... But may be is just my paranoia and nothing wrong there ?
http://www.footballglory.com/managers/m ... p?id=30530
http://www.footballglory.com/managers/m ... p?id=30102

_________________
Tr.
Manager of Borussia Dortmund BVB 09
Season 10 YFT winner

hmm, bit suspicous however I guess unless not the same IP, rule is not broken.

_________________
SK Slavia Praha

GIF


NEVER CHANGED TEAM

not sure but isnt 8 mil for a 16y old with 568 points cheap

http://www.footballglory.com/players/player.php?id=65985

I would maybe say between 10 and 15, so he got a good deal. Dont think it should be reversed tho..

_________________
You'll Never Walk Alone

anyway, it is deal between two experienced managers, so no reversal even if he goes cheaper.

_________________
SK Slavia Praha

GIF


NEVER CHANGED TEAM

I've played this game for a long time, and I count on my fingers the times I've written here, but I do not mean that the transfer is not fair, but the way some coaches handle them. They leave doubts as to whether there is differential treatment between coaches and teams.
At the beginning of this season I made several proposals for Mirko Ciardi, send 3 emails to the coach to negotiate, being the last one quite objective, I asked how much he wanted for the player. I did not get any response, and I was astonished to see the player sold by 28M. I do not understand how some coaches handle transfers. It's not about whether or not to give more, that maybe yes, but not even a negotiation existed. Lets me think there are teams with favorable treatment.

SY

Second time this happened to me this season. My offer on Mirko Ciardi was much better than 28 mill.

_________________
Galatasaray

I lost!? Can you believe it?

If the manager was offered more money then he sold the player for then there is a reason to suspect something isn't right

_________________
MArk

what was your offer? and when did you offer the deal?

_________________

I think my offer was around 35 mill. I made the offer a few days before he was sold.

_________________
Galatasaray

I lost!? Can you believe it?

So what will the consequences be? It is clearly that this is cheating since Blille had the best bid days before he was sold. One can twist and turn, but this one is quite an obvious cheat.

_________________
Atletico Madrid
------------------------------------
The double: 29 & 48
Division 1 winner: 29,31-33,48-49,51-52 & 54
Cup winner: 29-30,48 & 53
World cup winner: 30 & 53-54
Youth tourney winner: 34 & 56
64/66 pts - div 1. s. 52

I've never had a friend turn his back on me so blatantly before just fyi.

Just putting in a word here, I put in an offer for the player, the other manager accepted it. It is a fair deal between 2 managers, so where exactly may I know is the basis for me allegedly "cheating"? I've never cheated in this game and I never will. I suggest you, Eirik, stop short of calling someone a "cheat", more so an OBVIOUS cheat when it was a totally fair deal. Had I wanted to cheat, I would already have done so but having played this game since I was literally a kid at 13 or 14 and being in this game since 2005, here I have a couple of people calling me a cheat?

How is this different from any deal in real life, where managers/teams have the liberty to choose whatever teams they sell to? I could choose to sell any player on my team to 1 manager for 10m and not sell it for 15m to another, it is the manager's decision to choose as long as it is within the rules (since this is a game). If it is to be regulated to such an extent when a fair deal is still considered "cheating", then every sale might as well be an auction. But evidently, this wasn't the case.

_________________
Olimpija
Division 3H

mate, these are serious words, you should be carefull using them

_________________
SK Slavia Praha

GIF


NEVER CHANGED TEAM

Cheat or not it is strange that you would ignore a higher offer for your player unless you had a problem with the other manager. You are pretty shrewd in the transfer department and often buy low and sell at a profit days/weeks later, but that's fine, unless it transpires that the selling manager is selling at a lower price, then it becomes suspicious because don't we all want the best price for our players?

_________________
MArk

http://www.footballglory.com/players/pl ... p?id=51524

manager left team same day

_________________
SK Slavia Praha

GIF


NEVER CHANGED TEAM

At the moment we have zero admins except from Bryan?

_________________
Atletico Madrid
------------------------------------
The double: 29 & 48
Division 1 winner: 29,31-33,48-49,51-52 & 54
Cup winner: 29-30,48 & 53
World cup winner: 30 & 53-54
Youth tourney winner: 34 & 56
64/66 pts - div 1. s. 52