Leotar used an illegal lineup too! He used an 25y.o GK above 50K!

_________________
John Paspatis
Iraklis Thessaloniki F.C

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4z_fSoYcAWo

Fair play to Independiente Santa Fe sticking to their word and playing the 24 year old again so it was fair for all teams. That score needs to be altered too

_________________
FC Chornomorets

The following YFT season, I propose to change the rules of punishment for the using illegal formation:

"6) Every match in which one team brakes these rules will be registered 3-0 for the ALL GROUP STAGE MATCHES FOR ALL OPPONENTS IN THAT GROUP! "

This change more severely punish for the violation, but at the same time does not create any disparities between honest teams in the group.

_________________
Tr.
Manager of Borussia Dortmund BVB 09
Season 10 YFT winner

Ok
i am changing back to it 3-0
and i will update rules at another tourney
please tell me what can we do at these situation

_________________

both of them +7 goal difference (if we count like 4-0) but zhenis scored more goal then stella. because of that zhenis reached quarter final

_________________

Tables updated
I will wait 2 days if you object anything or not (illegal lineup, tables, calculations etc.)
FC Sheriff banned from next tourney.

_________________

Correction at Play Off Round table:
think we play PO Final 10-14 November NOT October...

_________________
Tr.
Manager of Borussia Dortmund BVB 09
Season 10 YFT winner

fixed it
thanks

_________________

Am gutted, totally forgot to change my keeper. He was only waged at 52k though, I think the result should stick personally!!

rules are rules buddy

_________________
http://www.footballglory.com/clubhouse/ ... p?name=IST

When is the next round of games being played ?

_________________
http://www.footballglory.com/clubhouse/ ... p?name=IST

27th October

_________________
http://www.footballglory.com/clubhouse/ ... p?name=MOT
Motherwell FC - 3G

ok game has been registered with Newcastle

_________________
http://www.footballglory.com/clubhouse/ ... p?name=IST

Game registered

_________________
FC Chornomorets

I think we should state:

"6) Every match in which one team breaks these rules will be registered 3-0 for the opponent! If the opponent won by 3 goals or more an additional goal will be added to their score."

That way, we don't penalize a team that follows the rules and we at least take a step towards what the real result would/could have been. Thoughts?

_________________
Stephen Bartlet
Manager of Dundee United

In general I do not like the idea.

I would prefer to base the solution to this problem based on the principles of Fair Play, applied in group D - for violation of the offender deduct defeated 0-3 in all games in the group Under this option:
- The offending team is automatically eliminated from the struggle for access to the next stage;
- Only the results of the remaining games between the participants will determine the passage to the next stage of the tournament.

But if you go on this way, I would try to avoid other complications and state rule more cleary:
"6) Every match in which one team breaks these rules will be registered 3-0 for the opponent! If the opponent won by 4 goals or more an additional goal will be added to their score and final result will be 4-0."

_________________
Tr.
Manager of Borussia Dortmund BVB 09
Season 10 YFT winner

Quarter Final fixture is ready

_________________

Any update to this Fatih?

_________________
FC Chornomorets

SF fixtures should be:

Hadjuk v Chornomorets
Motherwell v Olimpija

Motherwell are in semi due to average age being 0.1yrs younger (If I understood rules correctly!)

_________________
http://www.footballglory.com/clubhouse/ ... p?name=MOT
Motherwell FC - 3G

Tournament Rules:

...
7) If a draw will be at qualification round, small average aged team will be counted as winner.
...
According tournament SEEDS table avg. age youngs :
Motherwell 21.67
Borussia Dortmund 21.22

What does it means? Yes, Dortmund win by avg. age rule!

_________________
Tr.
Manager of Borussia Dortmund BVB 09
Season 10 YFT winner